2010 In Review

On December 27, 2010, in HRExaminer, by John Sumser

2010 The Year That Was in HR2010

With little fanfare and a constant rush of incremental news bites, 2010 didn’t always feel like a lot was happening. In hindsight, there was a TON of structural change in the HR Industry. New powerhouses emerged. The focus of HR underwent a series of profound shifts. Years of impoverishment in marketing and sales investments began to show as structural weakness.

Here are the high points of the year we are wrapping up.

  • Continued Economic Insecurity and High Unemployment
    “It’s the economy, stupid.” That was the underlying theme of Bill Clinton’s successful political campaigns. It’s truer now than ever. Fear mongers try to scare HR Execs about pending attrition problems when the economy changes. The real issue is that organizational decision making is getting really conservative as people try to insulate themselves from making observable mistakes. The problem isn’t pending attrition, though. It’s that current attrition isn’t high enough.
  • Social Media Continues To Blur The Distinction Between Work and Family
    The bizarre notion that everyone should be polishing their social media image for the consumption of the resume police distracts from the larger question. Social Media in general (and Facebook in particular) allow no distinction between the public and private spheres. Everyone can know everything about everyone else when your friends, family and coworkers see the intimate details of your status updates. Stodgier companies are not getting comfortable with the increased casualness implied in this ground-leveling. Where hierarchical governance depends on a separation between work and not work, organizational effectiveness is declining.
  • Shifting Media Landscape
    Social media, changing generational dynamics, structural workforce changes and a rearrangement of priorities in HR and Recruiting are among the factors driving major change in the industry’s media landscape. Traffic to older more established properties are down. HR.com (-67%), Recruitingblogs(-57%), Workforce (-26%), ERE (-31%) and SHRM (-17%). New projects HRExaminer (our sentimental favorite) and TLNT are among the destinations to which traffic is flowing and increasing. Upstart Fistful of Talent (+57%) is growing rapidly. 2011 will be a major transition year for web based publications in the space. Harder to quantify decentralized journalism in blogs, web radio and Twitter are major forces in this redesign of the media ecology.
  • Workday Redefines The HR Software Category
    Have you noticed that legacy software always looks old and feels clunky? That’s because interface standards change faster than development teams can deliver code to an established customer base. The advantage of starting a software company from scratch is that you get to start where the standards are today. (The disadvantage is that you have to win accounts from existing contractual relationships with other providers.) Workday bravely entered the enterprise HR Software game this year. Their offering is reshaping the expectations of customers everywhere. Find your way to a place where you can see a demo.
  • SuccessFactors Changes The Conversation
    There are strongly mixed opinions about whether or not performance management is a good thing or a bad thing. But, operational managers will always prefer direct accountability to touchy freely concepts like synergy and teamwork. SuccessFactors, armed with massive promotional resources and a really good idea, has changed the fundamental HR conversation. Where HR’s role used to be administering the Performance Management and objective setting process, SuccessFactors makes it possible to use that process to drive execution at the line level. We’re noticing that people are busier and more effective everywhere we look.
  • Learning Takes Center Stage
    When growth was the norm, Recruiting was the best place to invest real HR dollars. Talent acquisition was always harder than talent development. Churn was an implicit part of the headcount equation. While it remains to be seen whether or not this is a permanent thing, Learning (we used to call it training) is moving to the forefront of strategic HR thinking. Making your workforce agile depends on being able to redeploy existing employees. Cheap video, YouTube production standards, Bite Sized content and employee self-service are turning the old Training Department into a cafeteria of choice. Talent Management is the phrase word used to describe this shift in priorities.
  • SABA Drives HR’s Role in Communications
    We reviewed SABA’s communications and collaboration toolset earlier this fall. While there will be some heated debate between IT and HR about who should be in charge of the collaboration environment, it seems like a logical win for HR. Collaboration is a world in which technology should be extremely transparent. As long as HR takes up the challenge and works to make the platform recede behind the energy of collaboration, this is an amazing new frontier. SABA is likely to continue to lead the way.
  • Video Grabs Traction
    Say all you want about the propensity of video to cause discrimination. Hiring managers want to see people before they interview them. While conservative HR decision making (see economic insecurity above) will keep video interviewing and screening out of some organizations for a while longer, it’s here to stay. Video saves travel money, time and creates an environment for better decision making. 2010 was the year that the trend moved decidedly towards the use of video.
  • Differentiation is at an All Time Low
    For the most part, you simply can’t tell one HRTech Vendor from another. And, the vendors don’t know it. They are so busy believing their flimsy marketing materials that they can’t see the erosion of their brand. This difficult state of affairs began when vendors cut their marketing and sales functions to protect their technical core. Without guidance from marketing and sales, the development teams created a whole slew of new functionality. It looks like a marketplace of Swiss Army Knife purveyors.

Those are the key notes from my 2011. What did you see?

 
  • Pingback: Tweets that mention HRX: 2010 In Review -- Topsy.com

  • http://twitter.com/Jason_J_Davis Jason Davis

    Enjoyed this post John. Here’s to a great 2011 for you, and for HR.

    -Jason

  • http://www.recruitinganimal.com RecruitingANIMAL

    You can’t tell one HRTech Vendor from another. They cut their marketing and sales functions. So the engineers went wild.

    Wouldn’t that make them all different? Or did the engineers, cut loose from the real world, all follow the same line of reasoning?

  • Jennifer Bowen

    I enjoyed the recap John. I think 2011 will be an interesting year for social media usage in recruiting and HR. The blurred line will be questioned and examined a bit more and we should start to see some firm lines drawn.

    Thanks!

  • http://www.hrexaminer.com John Sumser

    It’s not so much that the engineers went wild. The development teams did
    what they do…develop. Without marketing and sales feedback, there was
    little in the way of market guidance. The stuff now sounds the same because
    the marketing investment necessary to distinguish one from the other hasn’t
    been made. Engineers do engineering. MArketers and sales people do
    simplification. You need a healthy blend of both to make things work.

  • John Hollon

    John: Thanks for mentioning TLNT in here. Makes me happy that I’m not the only one noticing out growth. I expect the trends you mention here (for the media particularly) to only accelerate in 2011.

    Stay well and give me a call sometime. Maybe we can catch up in person the next time I am in San Francisco. And let me know the next time you have another dinner!!!

  • http://www.ere.net/ David Manaster

    A couple of quibbles about the “Shifting Media Landscape” bullet point:

    1.) I think that the Compete numbers that you refer to are less about an across-the-board trend of the young eating the old, and more about the lifecycle of HR publications in a recession. Properties that were mature pre-recession are fighting the headwinds of the economy to keep their readers. The natural state of their readership would be to decline simply because there are less professionals in this field then there were a year ago.

    The newer publications are building from extremely low (or in the case of TLNT.com and HRExaminer, non-existant) bases, so they have nowhere to go but up.

    There will be winners and losers among the mature properties and the upstarts, and there is definitely a thirst for new voices (as there has been for the decade+ that I have been observing the profession), but I believe that the larger economic trend is swamping the site-specific variations that we would normally see.

    2.) Compete’s numbers rarely match our servers traffic reports, and they often fluctuate wildly from month to month. For instance if you would have taken the same chart of Fistfuloftalent.com, TLNT.com and HRExaminer.com’s traffic in September rather then November, you would have concluded that TLNT and HRExaminer were flat since they launched and that FistfulofTalent had declined by 40% since December 2009. Compete charts vary directionally in addition to their raw numbers.

    Full disclosure: My company owns one of the “older, more established properties” (ERE.net) that John describes as declining, and one of the “new projects” (TLNT.com) that John describes as growing rapidly, so I have a couple of horses in this race.

  • Pingback: HRExaminer v1.47 | HR Examiner with John Sumser

Page 1 of 11
More in HRExaminer (614 of 801 articles)